Can Keloid Scars Be Removed? Understanding Treatment Options and Recurrence
Medically reviewed by the medical team at Legacy Dermatology
Key Points
- Keloids are raised, overgrown scars that extend beyond the original wound and do not stop growing on their own.
- They can develop after acne, piercings, surgery, or any injury, and are more common in people with darker skin tones.
- Treatment options include corticosteroid injections, silicone therapy, cryotherapy, and in some cases surgical removal.
- Keloids have a high recurrence rate, so combination therapy is often recommended to reduce the chance they come back.
- The right treatment depends on the size, location, and symptoms of the scar, as well as the patient's personal and family history.
- Legacy Dermatology in Algonquin, IL treats keloids with intralesional injections and other targeted approaches tailored to each patient.
If you have ever had a scar that kept growing long after the original wound healed, you may be dealing with a keloid. These overgrown scars can be frustrating, uncomfortable, and sometimes self-consciousness-inducing, especially when they form in visible areas like the ears, neck, or chest. The good news is that there are real treatment options. The honest answer is that managing keloids requires a little patience and, in many cases, more than one approach.
Here is what you need to know about what keloids are, why they form, and what a dermatologist can do to help.
What Is a Keloid, and How Is It Different from a Regular Scar?
When the skin heals after an injury, it produces collagen to close the wound. In most people, that process stops once the wound is covered. In some people, the body keeps producing collagen even after the wound is healed, creating a raised, thickened scar that extends beyond the original injury site. That is a keloid.
Keloids differ from hypertrophic scars, which are also raised but stay within the wound boundaries and often flatten over time on their own. Keloids do not self-resolve. They can continue to grow for months or years, and they tend to be firmer, shinier, and more irregular in shape than typical raised scars.
Keloids most commonly appear on the earlobes, shoulders, chest, upper back, and jawline, though they can form anywhere on the body after skin trauma.
Why Do Keloids Form?
Keloids can develop after any break in the skin, including:
- Acne lesions, especially deep or cystic acne
- Ear or body piercings
- Surgical incisions
- Burns or cuts
- Chickenpox or other infections that cause skin damage
- Vaccinations or injections
Not everyone who experiences these things will develop a keloid. Genetics play a significant role. If a parent or sibling has keloids, your likelihood of developing them is higher. Keloids are also more common in people with darker skin tones, including those of African, Hispanic, and Asian descent, though they can occur in anyone.
The exact biological reason some people overproduce collagen is still being studied, but research published in the Journal of Cell Communication and Signaling points to abnormal fibroblast activity and disrupted signaling pathways in the wound-healing process as contributing factors.
What Are the Available Treatment Options?
There is no single treatment that works for every keloid, and no treatment guarantees permanent results. What a dermatologist will typically do is assess the scar and recommend a plan based on its size, location, age, and how it has responded to any prior treatment.
Corticosteroid injections are one of the most commonly used treatments. Injecting a steroid directly into the keloid, a technique called intralesional injection, can flatten and soften the scar over a series of sessions. Kenalog (triamcinolone acetonide) is a commonly used medication for this purpose. Injections are usually spaced several weeks apart, and results vary depending on the size and age of the keloid.
Silicone therapy involves applying silicone gel sheets or ointment to the scar over an extended period. It is a noninvasive option that works best for smaller or newer keloids and is sometimes used alongside other treatments to help maintain results.
Cryotherapy uses liquid nitrogen to freeze the scar tissue. It can be effective for smaller keloids, though it may cause temporary skin lightening, which is an important consideration for patients with darker skin tones.
Surgical removal is sometimes appropriate, particularly for large or symptomatic keloids, but surgery alone has a high recurrence rate. Because cutting into the skin to remove a keloid can itself trigger a new keloid, surgical removal is usually combined with another treatment, such as corticosteroid injections or radiation therapy, to reduce the chance of regrowth.
Other options, such as laser therapy and pressure therapy, may be appropriate in certain cases. Your dermatologist can walk through what is available based on your specific scar and medical history.
Why Do Keloids Come Back After Treatment?
Keloid recurrence is one of the most challenging aspects of managing this condition. The underlying tendency to overproduce collagen does not go away with treatment, so the skin can respond the same way again after a procedure or even after the skin is simply disturbed during treatment.
Studies have reported recurrence rates after surgical excision alone that can exceed 50 percent in some cases, which is why standalone surgery is rarely recommended. Combining treatments, such as pairing excision with post-operative corticosteroid injections or compression therapy, is associated with better long-term outcomes.
Being transparent with your dermatologist about your history with keloids, including whether you have had them before and how they responded to previous treatment, helps build a plan that takes your personal recurrence risk into account.
Who Is More Likely to Develop Keloids?
Some individuals are simply more prone to keloid formation. Risk factors include:
- A personal or family history of keloids
- Darker skin tones, particularly Black, Hispanic, and Asian skin
- Being younger, as keloids are most common between the ages of 10 and 30
- Having had keloids form after a previous injury or procedure
If you know you are prone to keloids, it is worth discussing this with any provider before undergoing elective procedures, piercings, or surgeries so that preventive measures can be taken.
When Should You See a Dermatologist About a Scar?
Not every raised scar needs immediate treatment, but there are situations where it is worth making an appointment:
- The scar is growing beyond the original wound site
- It is itchy, tender, or painful
- It is affecting movement, especially near a joint
- It is causing distress because of its location or appearance
- You are unsure whether the scar is a keloid or something else that may need a different evaluation
A dermatologist can confirm the diagnosis, discuss your options honestly, and help you set realistic expectations for treatment. Some keloids respond well and stay flat for years. Others are more stubborn. Either way, knowing what you are dealing with is a useful starting point.
Schedule a Keloid Consultation at Legacy Dermatology
Legacy Dermatology in Algonquin, IL evaluates and treats keloids using approaches that fit each patient's scar type, skin tone, and history. If you have a scar that is growing, uncomfortable, or simply not going away, the team can help you understand your options.
Legacy Dermatology
2230 Huntington Drive N, Unit C-1
Algonquin, IL 60102
(847) 603-4146
Frequently Asked Questions About Keloid Scars
Can keloid scars be removed permanently?
There is no treatment that guarantees keloids will not return. Treatments can significantly flatten, soften, or reduce a keloid, but because the tendency to overproduce collagen is a biological trait, some people remain at risk of recurrence. Combination therapy generally offers the best chance of long-lasting results.
Do keloid injections hurt?
Corticosteroid injections involve a brief sting at the injection site. Most patients find it tolerable, especially for smaller keloids. The area may feel tender for a day or two afterward. Your provider can discuss ways to manage discomfort during and after the procedure.
How many injections does it take to treat a keloid?
Most patients need a series of injections, typically spaced four to six weeks apart. The number depends on the size and thickness of the keloid and how it responds to treatment. Some patients see significant improvement after three to four sessions; others may need more.
Is surgery a good option for keloids?
Surgical removal can be appropriate for certain keloids, particularly large ones that are causing physical symptoms. However, surgery alone carries a significant recurrence risk, so it is typically combined with another treatment to reduce the chance the keloid grows back.
Can I prevent keloids from forming after a piercing or surgery?
If you know you are prone to keloids, letting your provider know before any procedure is the first step. Post-procedure silicone sheets, compression, and early corticosteroid injections at the first sign of abnormal scarring can all help reduce the likelihood of a keloid developing.
Are keloids dangerous?
Keloids are not medically dangerous. They are benign overgrowths of scar tissue. However, they can be itchy, tender, painful, or emotionally distressing, all of which are valid reasons to seek treatment.
Frequently Asked Questions About Legacy Dermatology
Does Legacy Dermatology treat keloids?
Yes. Legacy Dermatology offers evaluation and treatment for keloids, including intralesional injections. Treatment plans are tailored based on the scar's size, location, and your personal history.
Where is Legacy Dermatology located?
We are located at 2230 Huntington Drive N, Unit C-1, Algonquin, IL 60102. We serve patients from Algonquin, Lake in the Hills, Crystal Lake, Carpentersville, and surrounding communities.
How do I make an appointment?
Call (847) 603-4146 or schedule online. New patients are welcome.
Does Legacy Dermatology treat other types of scars?
Yes. In addition to keloids, Legacy Dermatology offers treatments for acne scars, hyperpigmentation, and other skin concerns. The team can evaluate your skin and recommend the most appropriate approach for your situation.
What should I bring to a keloid consultation?
Bring your insurance card, a list of any current medications, and information about any prior treatments you have tried for the scar. If you had a previous biopsy or procedure related to the scar, bringing those records can also be helpful.
Disclaimer: The information provided on this blog is for general informational purposes only and is not intended as, and should not be considered, medical advice. All information, content, and material available on this blog are for general informational purposes only. Readers are advised to consult with a qualified healthcare professional for medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. The author and the blog disclaim any liability for the decisions you make based on the information provided. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition.




